 |
06-12-2012, 01:19 PM
|
#1
|
|
@paper_gangsta_
Join Date: Nov 2010
Location: Wishan!gg@ Woods
Posts: 1,301
|
Effect veiler?
Ok, so, a couple scenarios I have questions about
Scenario 1
I flip summon Morphing Jar
effect goes on chain link 1
opponent responds veiler
CL1: Jar
CL2: Veiler
I respond Book of Moon
CL1: Jar
CL2: Veiler
CL3: Book
My jar goes face down
veiler fizzles
ditch, draw 5. right?
I have a question more or less about
Scenario 2
I flip summon Morphing Jar
CL1: Jar
Opponent Responds veiler
CL1: Jar
CL2: Veiler
I respond Book
CL1: Jar
CL2: Veiler
CL3: Book
Opponent responds veiler
CL1: Jar
CL2: Veiler
CL3: Book
CL4. Veiler
What happens? since it is a different object while facedown, does the effect resolve?
__________________
2011s MTG South Carolina State Champion. 4 YGO Reg Tops. 6 Top 16s. 7 MTG SCG IQ Top 8s (2 wins, 1 final, 2 top fours). Featured Writer for Pojo. Level 1 Judge in Yugioh. Level 1 Judge in Magic: The Gathering.
Check out me new Trade thread/Store!
|
|
|
|
06-12-2012, 01:27 PM
|
#2
|
|
Pojo Veteran
Join Date: Jan 2012
Posts: 1,668
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Themcshakealchemis
Ok, so, a couple scenarios I have questions about
Scenario 1
I flip summon Morphing Jar
effect goes on chain link 1
opponent responds veiler
CL1: Jar
CL2: Veiler
I respond Book of Moon
CL1: Jar
CL2: Veiler
CL3: Book
My jar goes face down
veiler fizzles
ditch, draw 5. right?
I have a question more or less about
Scenario 2
I flip summon Morphing Jar
CL1: Jar
Opponent Responds veiler
CL1: Jar
CL2: Veiler
I respond Book
CL1: Jar
CL2: Veiler
CL3: Book
Opponent responds veiler
CL1: Jar
CL2: Veiler
CL3: Book
CL4. Veiler
What happens? since it is a different object while facedown, does the effect resolve? |
In both scenarios "Morphing Jar" will resolve with effect. The resolution of "Effect Veiler" is meaningless if the mosnter is facedown before it(the monster being targetted resolves).
If the effect of Effect Veiler resolves, and the targeted monster is then flipped face-down, its effect(s) will no longer be negated, even if it is flipped face-up again later that turn.[1]
__________________
Dueling Network Junior Administrator
Head Judge of Pink Bunny Games LLC
YCS Chicago 2012 Floor Judge
Evo Game Regional 2012 Floor Judge
Misty Mountain Regional 2012 Floor Judge
Lindenhurst Regional 2012 Floor Lead
Future Evo Game Regional 2013 Floor Judge
|
|
|
|
|
06-12-2012, 01:31 PM
|
#3
|
|
@paper_gangsta_
Join Date: Nov 2010
Location: Wishan!gg@ Woods
Posts: 1,301
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by The Chief
In both scenarios "Morphing Jar" will resolve with effect. The resolution of "Effect Veiler" is meaningless if the mosnter is facedown before it(the monster being targetted resolves).
If the effect of Effect Veiler resolves, and the targeted monster is then flipped face-down, its effect(s) will no longer be negated, even if it is flipped face-up again later that turn.[1] |
okay, thank you so much. Iwasnt sure since the effect of one veiler had resolved 
__________________
2011s MTG South Carolina State Champion. 4 YGO Reg Tops. 6 Top 16s. 7 MTG SCG IQ Top 8s (2 wins, 1 final, 2 top fours). Featured Writer for Pojo. Level 1 Judge in Yugioh. Level 1 Judge in Magic: The Gathering.
Check out me new Trade thread/Store!
|
|
|
|
Posting Rules
|
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
HTML code is Off
|
|
|
|
|
|
