2 Kingdome Hearts sig. one really old, and one new

[Peanut_Chuck Brown]

ok let me know what you think. i beleive you can tell which is old and which is new.

http://img358.imageshack.us/img358/9914/soraxasbmp0rx.png

http://img475.imageshack.us/img475/3067/khsig11rz.gif

[GooberGrape513]

LOL...I like the old one more, even if it is kinda bad(ish).

The new one's stock doesn't match the bg AT ALL.
Animated sigs are usually a minus also.

Good job though.

EDIT:
The first one is the old one and the animated one is the new one? If I got it backwards then just switch the words around...

[Peanut_Chuck Brown]

yup, you got them backwards :D. i guess people cant tell which is old and which is new, lol. thanks for the advice!

[Flames of a Phoenix]

The old one looks too suggestive (placement of Keyblade and his face).

The newer one is stagnant and the text is poorly placed. Make it smaller or make the banner wider so that it doesn't look so clunky.

[Busterslash35]

The old one looks too suggestive (placement of Keyblade and his face).
ROFL.

Flames actually made me laugh. Lawlz.

I don't like the .gif... the animation is just... simple. Too simple. The first one is just bad placement n stuff...