New idea for Yugioh [Archive]

Robbie

01-30-2006, 06:33 PM

OogaBooga

01-30-2006, 06:38 PM

So... anyone could use Chaos Emperor Dragon - Envoy of the End in their decks?

Not a chance.

I don't approve of a "medium" format between Advanced and Traditional. I prefer Advanced format, but I don't mind playing in Traditional with all the banned cards either. I never felt a need for a new format.

demonstalk

01-30-2006, 06:41 PM

Its a nice dream, I would like to see them bring traditinal back for a little while but thats why they have ceartin tourneys for that.

lordjar

01-30-2006, 06:43 PM

I think that what we are working with is good enough...

there is a reason why there is a banned/restriced list in the first place.

It's to promote new deck ideas... which is what has happened for the last 4 months... No BLS has spawned such new deck types as the Menae Engine, Wildheart/Last Turn (Props to Yami_Michael), Bazoo RFG, Turbo Merchant, and more that I currently may or may not remember.

Give the Advanced Format more of a chance... Traditional is terrible anyways.

Scrubby

01-30-2006, 06:43 PM

Seriously, if we could use 1 card on the ban list i would be pretty mad. Last thing i want is to have to face a BLS or CED or a piece of the trinity again >.>

Shadow of Death

01-30-2006, 06:56 PM

Looks like a little black crow will be a mighty happy person if UDE considers this.

soraokyut

01-30-2006, 07:01 PM

Well in calgary for the hobby league tournies, the owner of the store where I play at allow you to use 2 cards from the forbidden/restriced list...

For example:
2 pot of greed
2 change of heart
1 sinister, 1 Graceful Charity

Since you can change your deck every week it allow to use new ideas. For example I ran a Phoniex control deck using Graceful, 3 mobius, 2 night assilant, 2 ASF, and other cost discard cards.... Actually it was quite fun (19 people played). I won with it. There was things like rageki, IO, and Fiber. It really made things interseting.

This allowed some creativity and it didn't feel broken since everyone chose something different to run.

rarnom

01-30-2006, 08:24 PM

Since no one in my area these days likes the traditional format...

That's because they all realized that traditional is JUNK.

Still, interesting idea, I bet lots of people would just run Yata. Dons, reapers, drop off's and Yata. No way UDE would consider it. It is enough of a luxury that players even have traditional as an option at all.

Hazen

01-30-2006, 08:25 PM

ew. jsut no. I've had enough Yata to last the rest of my life.

canukleheads

01-30-2006, 08:32 PM

Being allowed the two banned cards is actually a lot of fun, because 19 poeple all tried different things with what they could have. Personally, I'm goin to try Painful Choice and probably Harpie's Feather in an E-Hero deck. I can't wait for sunday...plus the Sehawks are in the Super Bowl, GO C'HAWKS!

ImNotSav

01-30-2006, 08:35 PM

eww banned cards are nasty, lol. not a bad idea but everyone should just stick to advanced or traditional unless you just wanna use the idea with some friends.

Wardog369

01-30-2006, 08:38 PM

I don't know where you are but this game is far from going down. This is really the next MTG, that is the way I see it. You also obvisosly have never played before the ban list as well.

sparks

01-30-2006, 08:38 PM

if they are going to try and get more people playing I think they should make another tv series. I mean, the orginal series got the majority of the people playing and the with gx even more came back to this game

Sasuke Samurai1013

01-30-2006, 08:41 PM

Since no one in my area these days likes the traditional format and i think that the state of yugioh is dieing. I propse that upperdeck makes a rule saying that we can use anyone card on the ban list. This idea would revive old decks and keep the game of yugioh alive. This thought has been around a while now so i want opinions if this idea should come into reality.
Just ewww. I don't even want to think about being yata locked again those cards are banned for a reason. even alowing duelists to chose one would wreck the game.

Satisfaction

01-30-2006, 09:32 PM

tuts ridiculous, it shouldn't happen, if they do tut than the yugioh will be screwed up. Yugioh is not dying its getting bigger and bigger.

Robbie

01-30-2006, 09:33 PM

I don't know where you are but this game is far from going down. This is really the next MTG, that is the way I see it. You also obvisosly have never played before the ban list as well.

NICE assumption. I remember the days of 3 mst's, 3 ddwl, a full hand control deck, including forceful, delinquet, yata, con, etc. Inaddition I have played in over 10 states in over 60 different tourneys for the last couple of years. But I must be new at this. Surely I can't know what i'm talking about!!

Overall, the game has lost its edge, and if UDE doens't try something else new, in short order, we will all be talking about "that yugi-oh fade thing". However, I truley hope Upper Deck will make a revolutionary change to the game, for the better.

ADAMCAT

01-30-2006, 09:33 PM

yeah , i agree with satisfaction...

Paladinseer007

01-30-2006, 10:08 PM

Since no one in my area these days likes the traditional format and i think that the state of yugioh is dieing. I propse that upperdeck makes a rule saying that we can use anyone card on the ban list. This idea would revive old decks and keep the game of yugioh alive. This thought has been around a while now so i want opinions if this idea should come into reality.

Actually I like that idea, and I agree with what you are saying as well. But may I suggest if may, that to increase the one card number up to say two or maybe even four as a bit a twist and also as a challenge too.:D

cj_simmons

01-31-2006, 01:15 AM

Since no one in my area these days likes the traditional format and i think that the state of yugioh is dieing. I propse that upperdeck makes a rule saying that we can use anyone card on the ban list. This idea would revive old decks and keep the game of yugioh alive. This thought has been around a while now so i want opinions if this idea should come into reality.

sorry but no. just can't say that i like that idea.

scientist decks whould pwn all

JTakaS4

01-31-2006, 01:40 AM

i could start using imperial order again with my last turn deck and make everyone mad.

or i could use bls in my last turn deck again and make everyone mad

or i could use scientist and in my last turn deck and make everyone mad

or i could use butterfly dagger in my last turn deck and make everyone mad

or i could use......no that's about it

Xaylen

01-31-2006, 03:45 AM

With THAT idea,we might as well have no Ban List..=/

[X]

Robbie

01-31-2006, 05:30 PM

Think of how many CC deck there are....3....4....5 If anyone will be able to use a single card on the band list that would yet again spawn a whole new era of deck ideas. This is only something to consider. So far, it seems as though those who have posted do not like the idea because they do not want to see any of those cards used against them. I can agree with that. However, I would be more excited about being able to use any 1 card. This would unlock thousands of different options for everyone. Not just the 3 or 4 CC decks, if thats what you choose.

Iron butterfly

01-31-2006, 07:52 PM

I don't know where you are but this game is far from going down. This is really the next MTG,
If MTG had more n00bs, less combos, and alot more game unbalance..

Advanced is fine as is besides Pot of Greed ban. Revoke that and it would be perfect. Yugioh doesn't have alot of card advantage, and it's stupid to have a creature support of Pot of Greed if the pot is banned..

Dascove

01-31-2006, 08:49 PM

If MTG had more n00bs, less combos, and alot more game unbalance..

Advanced is fine as is besides Pot of Greed ban. Revoke that and it would be perfect. Yugioh doesn't have alot of card advantage, and it's stupid to have a creature support of Pot of Greed if the pot is banned..

At the time the cards were made PoG wasn't banned. And Pot needs to stay banned, it was a no cost 2 for 1. Every card on the list needed it. The removal of such generic cards from the game along with more and more theme support will eventually leed to a game without a CC deck. Or one with dozens of them, basicly eleminating the CC anyway.

Piroko

01-31-2006, 08:52 PM

You know, of all the resolutions to edit the ban list formats, none have ever fallen through.

I don't really recommend trying again. =/