you know I think I figured out the random card change for the next ban list

[Dragon Warrior]

well you know how every ban list has something in it that seems out of place

does magic cylinder deserve to be limited?

I mean it doesnt destroy the monster which is the main reason it isnt used much. It isnt chainable so mobius still owns it. Also making it semi limited could make odion/trap burner decks viable.

so everyone post your thoughts on semi limiting magic cylinder

[HolyDraconus]

never...... at least with our current card pool

[Faust_8]

It's Forbidden for one reason only:

You could activate 3 of them in response to one attack.

[Kameiko]

It's Forbidden for one reason only:

You could activate 3 of them in response to one attack.

You mean restricted? ^_^!

Yes that be very very mean though.

Also it targets so say bye bye to Spirit Reaper!

[Kensh0rz]

Decisions regarding forbidding things in this game are never random. Poorly thought out maybe, but never random.

If it was Semi'd, it probably still wouldn't see too much play unless we lost a number of other traps. After all, we don't want to burn the other player for 2100 when they try smack to you with Cyber Dragon - we want it dead.

[PMasterS]

It's Forbidden for one reason only:

You could activate 3 of them in response to one attack.



No you couldn't it negates the attack, so the second and third couldn't resolve as there would no longer be an attacking monster.

[Kameiko]

No you couldn't it negates the attack, so the second and third couldn't resolve as there would no longer be an attacking monster.

ummm....yeah thats why you can activate sakretsu armor and chain it to Magic Cylinder.

The move is perfectly leagal waht Faust_8 said, unles someone can prove us wrong >_>